« So we're getting screwed on the Blackberry Storm -- so what? | Main | 083 in business »

TrackBack

TrackBack URL for this entry:
http://www.typepad.com/services/trackback/6a00d8341ebf2053ef010535fb6462970b

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Why uploading photos to Flickr is against the law:

Comments

Simon McGarr

I don't see where, on the DPC site page you've linked to that they say something akin to what you're asserting.

I think you've overstated your case. Digital Rights Ireland have a good pamphlet covering these and other issues relevant to photographers.


adrian

The general principle is that if you take a photo of someone, you are now a data controller (whether you like it or not).
As such, you now have to adhere to data protection rules on how you 'process' that data. And that means getting consent for posting picture on public websites like Flickr.

The rules are supposed to reinforce the principle that a person has a right to how their image is used. So you can't go around taking photos people -- no matter where they are -- and use those images fro whatever you like.

For commercial purposes (Babes of Grafton Street Calendar 2009), for example.

There is a derogation in the legislation for artistic, literary or journalistic purposes. Presumable some (most?) bloggers see themselves in one or other of those categories, even if the data protection commissioner (or the circuit court, on appeal) is unlikely to agree.

Orlaith

That's handy to know. I found out recently that my boyfriend had made his Picasa web albums public. To make it easier for anyone to view our holiday snaps etc he had the link to our photo albums as a signature on his email. That's actually how I stumbled upon it, to my horror. Naturally I threatened to sue him for copyright infringement and that put a stop to it.

adrian

Ha ha! Actually, Orlaith, that's not copyright infringement at all -- he has the copyright to the photos. But you have rights over your images in his copyrighted pictures. So if I go and use those pictures on my blog, I have to get two sets of permissions -- yours for the data privacy and his for the copyright.

orlaith

Oh I see. well, hopefully, all this will make people think twice before indulging their compulsion to share embarrassing photos of loved ones with the wider world!

adrian

Like hell it will!

The comments to this entry are closed.