Eircom settles with Big Music: will cut off file-sharers

Eircom has settled its case with the big music labels, which were suing it to take more action against illegal file-sharers. If the music labels come to it with IP addresses that they have identified as illegal file-sharers, Eircom will, in its own words:

"1) inform its broadband subscribers that the subscribers IP address has been detected infringing copyright and

"2) warn the subscriber that unless the infringement ceases the subscriber will be disconnected and

"3) in default of compliance by the subscriber with the warning it will disconnect the subscriber"

Sound like a climbdown by Eircom? Not so, says its head of communications, Paul Bradley.

"They wanted to get into our network, to implement a technological solution," he told me a few minutes ago. "Instead, they've agreed they're not getting that. They're going to get a third party to go off and try and gather information themselves as to who is using our network to file-share illegally. It's a key difference."

And then?

"What happens at the moment is that music labels need to go to court to get an order asking us to shut off a subscriber's connection. Under the compromise, they will come to us, using the same standard of proof they would have given the court. We need to be convinced that our subscriber is file-sharing illegally."

Comments

[Thomas Brunkard]

Ouch. Have very little sympathy for the recorded music industry. Would favour this if MP3's were not so ridiculously over priced - a low quality delivered at next to zero cost for the price of the CD. I'm sure this will stop file sharing on Eircom for about two weeks till a circumventing measure appears.

[Gerard Cunningham]

According to Silicon Republic, 'The labels wanted Eircom to install filtering software such as Audible Magic to help prevent the rise of music piracy which coincided with and they believe is responsible for falling music sales'.

A google for 'bypass Audible Magic' suggests that getting past the barrier is relatively trivial. so what does that leave us with? An assumption of guilt against any subscriber with a heavy usage pattern?

[Leon Quinn]

As soon as everyone realises its pointless to try stop these downloads the better. The music companies should stop wasting time and money on legalities and think of beter and cheaper ways to distribute their mucis!

[Antoin O Lachtnain]

Does this apply to all illegal activity on the Internet? What about wikipedia vandalism, for instance?

[Anderson Ward]

I us PeerGuardian 2 to block both Eircom and IrishBroadband from tracing my P2P activity. It works..

[Justin Mason]

Anderson: for now. Apps like PeerGuardian will be working adversarially against the investigative companies like Dtecnet, so it's going to be cat and mouse for the foreseeable future, I'd reckon, with Dtecnet finding ways around their blocklists and vice-versa. (this has parallels in my own experience in the anti-spam field ;)

fwiw, I blogged some followup thoughts at http://taint.org/2009/01/29/111355a.html

[celebrities]

instead of holding on to fancy prices, these music companies could sell cheaper so the increased sales volume would generate desired profit

[Silky Upskirt]

yes.. attractive post!

[video]

yes,Music companies must reduce their prices to sell large volume.Consumer also benefit on buying those music videos

[hairy pussy]

Under the compromise, they will come to us, using the same standard of proof they would have given the court. We need to be convinced that our subscriber is file-sharing illegally."

[black porn]

instead of holding on to fancy prices, these music companies could sell cheaper so the increased sales volume would generate desired profit

[jessica simpson naked]

instead of holding on to fancy prices, these music companies could sell cheaper so the increased sales volume would generate desired profit

[Bağlama Büyüsü]

instead of holding on to fancy prices, these music companies could sell cheaper so the increased sales volume would generate desired profit

[Cut machine]

Applications such as PeerGuardian adversarially be working against companies like Dtecnet research, so it will be cat and mouse in the near future, I would have Dtecnet finding the shape of their lists of blocks and vice versa.

[Soaps opera spoilers]

You have little sympathy for the recorded music industry. This would favor if MP3 were not so ridiculously overpriced - a low quality delivery with no cost to the price of the CD.

[First up gazebo]

I have little sympathy for the recorded music industry but...

[Cartuse]

Does this apply to all illegal activities on the Internet? What about vandalism wikipedia, for example?

[Boats seat pedestal]

I us PeerGuardian 2 to block both Eircom and IrishBroadband from tracing my P2P activity. It works.

[first up gazebo]

As soon as everyone realises its pointless to try stop these downloads the better. The music companies should stop wasting time and money on legalities and think of beter and cheaper ways to distribute their mucis!

[New Balance Shoes]

Dare and the world always yields. If it beats you sometimes, dare it again and again and it will succumb. Do you think so?

[clay bar detailing]

wow they have really been cutting down all these types of file sharing copanies latley hey. just recently i heard that they shut down twelve large websies and also siued and inprisoned the owners of piratebay.org..

[new balance]

Only those who have the patience to do simple things perfectly ever acquire the skill to do difficult things easily .

[Impotence causes]

Sex, pornography, these two issues are often very sensitive to deal with when you get to have children, I am one of those parents who prefer to educate their children at home rather than learn the wrong things with friends or in schools, I think many more parents should think the same way, so would avoid large numbers of unwanted pregnancies. Thanks!

[Supra Shoes]

May peace and love fill your heart, beauty fill your world, and contentment and joy fill your days.

[Jordan 12]

The great pleasure in life is doing what people say you can not do

[Supra Shoes]

I completely agree! I also find by doing something that makes a difference, an impact, keeps you healthier as well. Healthier in body, mind and spirit. Thank you for commenting!

[Air Jordans]

To conclude this endless pain

[jordan france]

oh so funny!

[UGG Shoes]

i love you post

[nike air max]

Good suggestions as usual!

[Air Jordan]

I just wish I knew what to do!@

[nike air max]

*One of these days is none of these days!!!

[moncler jackets]

oh, I really like the style of your writing!